10. CODE OF PHARMACEUTICAL ETHICS

CODE OF PHARMACEUTICAL ETHICS

The philosophical study of moral phenomena is known as ethics or moral philosophy. It looks into normative issues such as what ethically correct action is or what people should do. Typically, it is separated into three main areas: metaethics, applied ethics, and normative ethics. The code of moral principles or the science of morals is termed as ethics.

The pharmacy profession possesses noble ideas and pious nature. It has been a career for earning livelihood and has also got the attitude of service and sacrifice in the interests of suffering humanity. Charaka stated that “Even if your own life be in danger you should not betray or neglect the interests of your patients”. This saying should be valued by each pharmacist.

ETHICAL PRINCIPLES

Consumer

• Recognising the Consumer’s Health and Well-being as the First Priority: Make use of expert knowledge and provide care compassionately and professionally.
• Respecting the Consumer’s Autonomy and Rights: Respect dignity, privacy, individuality, and right to refuse advice/treatment. Maintain privacy and confidentiality of information.

Community

• Upholding the Reputation and Public Trust of the Profession: Not abuse the trust and respect of individuals and society.
• Acknowledging Professional Roles and Responsibilities: Maintain accountable control and supply of therapeutic goods; contribute to public health; enhance quality use of medicines.

Pharmacy Profession

• Demonstrating Commitment to Development: Involve in training staff, teaching, mentoring, professional leadership.
• Maintaining Contemporary Knowledge and Competence: Lifelong learning, self-development, personal health.
• Practising Under Conditions Upholding Independence and Integrity: Exercise professional autonomy, objectivity, independence; manage conflicts of interest.

Business Practices

Conducting the pharmacy business ethically and professionally in the best interest of the consumer, paying due respect to colleagues, and upholding the reputation of the profession.

Other Healthcare Professionals

Working collaboratively with other health professionals for optimising the health outcomes of consumers.

ETHICAL PROBLEM SOLVING

Categories of Ethical Problems

1. Ethical Violations: Failure to offer appropriate pharmaceutical services due to negligence of moral commitments.
2. Ethical Dilemmas: Ethical arguments for and against a given course of action; only one option must be chosen.
3. Ethical Distress: Pharmaceutical personnel subjected to procedures that make them feel guilty, concerned, or disgusted.

Ethical Decision-Making Framework (5 Steps)

1. Identify the Issue and Examine the Facts:
   • Is this a clear case of right and wrong?
   • What is the ethical issue or dilemma?
   • What are the most important facts?
   • What are the wishes of the patient?
2. Apply Guidelines and Standards:
   • What does the Code of Ethics say?
   • Relevant legislation, policies, or guidelines?
   • Consult colleagues or the College if needed.
3. Evaluate Possible Resolutions:
   • Choose at least three alternative courses of action.
   • Evaluate advantages and disadvantages of each.
   • Consider: Does it prioritise the patient? Tolerate public scrutiny? Serve as model for future behaviour?
4. Implement and Document Decision-Making:
   • Select the most appropriate plan of action and carry it out.
   • Write down reasons for selection.
5. Review and Reflect:
   • Evaluate the decision’s outcome.
   • What did I learn? What could I have done differently?
   • Share learned skills with colleagues.

CODE OF ETHICS FOR PHARMACIST

In Relation to His Job

• Scope of Pharmaceutical Services: Provide complete pharmaceutical services including emergency services without delay.
• Conduct of the Pharmacy: Premises should avoid contamination risk; professional character reflected by appearance; display notice for ESIS/Government schemes.
• Handling of Prescriptions:
  • Do not discuss or comment on therapeutic efficacy with patient.
  • Do not show alarm or astonishment.
  • Cannot add, remove, or replace ingredients without prescriber’s approval.
  • Refer errors in prescription back to prescriber.
• Handling of Drugs: Use correct scales and measures; avoid visual estimations; never use spurious, substandard, or unethical preparations.
• Apprentice Pharmacist: Provide trainees with all work facilities; ensure sufficient technique and skill before granting certificate.

In Relation to His Trade

• Price Structure: Price should include quality, quantity, labour, and responsibility of pharmacist; customer should not be burdened with excessive taxes.
• Fair Trade Practice:
  • No prizes, gifts, or allurement to patronisers.
  • No intentional lower prices to capture business.
  • Do not accept prescriptions meant for other dispensaries.
  • Do not copy labels, trademarks, signs of contemporaries.
• Purchase of Drugs: Purchase only from genuine and reliable sources; do not assist in manufacture or sale of spurious drugs.
• Hawking of Drugs: Drugs should not be hawked or sold door-to-door; no self-service method.
• Advertising and Displays:
  • No wording/design reflecting on other pharmacists.
  • No misleading or exaggerated claims.
  • No use of word “cure”.
  • No guarantee of therapeutic efficacy.
  • No prize, competition, or similar schemes.
  • No reference to sexual weakness, premature ageing, or loss of virility.

In Relation to His Medical Profession

• Limitation of Professional Activity: Should not practice medicine (diagnosing diseases and prescribing medicines). May help with first aid in emergencies. Should not recommend a particular medical practitioner unless asked.
• Clandestine Arrangements: No secret agreement or contract with physician for commission or advantage.
• Libation with Public: Keep knowledge upgraded; do not reveal information acquired during professional activities to any third person unless required by law.

In Relation to His Profession

• Professional Vigilance: Be law-abiding; prevent offensive activities; help bring miscreants to book; cooperate with fellow members.
• Law-Abiding Citizen: Possess fair knowledge of laws of the land; comply with enactments related to food, drug, pharmacy, health, sanitation.
• Relationship with Professional Organisations: Connect with and motivate organisations favouring scientific, moral, and cultural well-being of pharmacists.
• Decorum and Propriety: Avoid activities against the dignity of pharmaceutical profession.

PHARMACIST’S OATH

1. I swear by the Code of Ethics of Pharmacy Council of India in relation to the community and shall act as an integral part of healthcare team.
2. I shall uphold the laws and standards governing my profession.
3. I shall strive to perfect and enlarge my knowledge to contribute to the advancement of pharmacy and public health.
4. I shall follow the system which I consider best for pharmaceutical care and counselling of patient.
5. I shall endeavour to discover and manufacture drugs of quality to alleviate sufferings of humanity.
6. I shall hold in confidence the knowledge gained about the patients in connection with my professional practice and never divulge unless compelled to do so by the law.
7. I shall associate with organisations having their objectives for betterment of profession of pharmacy and make contribution to carry out the work of these organisations.
8. While I continue to keep this oath inviolate, may it be granted to me to enjoy life and practice of pharmacy respected by all, at all times! Should I trespass and violate the oath, may the reverse be my lot.

SUMMARY TABLE

Category	Key Ethical Requirements
Consumer	Health as first priority; respect autonomy and confidentiality
Community	Uphold reputation; contribute to public health
Profession	Lifelong learning; professional autonomy; manage conflicts of interest
Business Practices	Ethical conduct; best interest of consumer
Healthcare Professionals	Collaborative work for optimal health outcomes